Skip to main content
Legia

IT Infrastructure & Cloud

Linux or Windows Server for Office Needs

Choosing a server operating system is rarely a matter of taste. The applications you must run, the licensing model, the support lifecycle, and the skills of the team maintaining it usually decide first. This comparison helps you read them.

SEO and Content Specialist

9 min read

Blue network cables leading to a switch panel

Short answer: choose Windows Server if the office uses Active Directory to manage accounts and Windows computers, or runs applications that are only supported on Windows, such as .NET Framework and ASP.NET Web Forms applications. Choose Linux for web application servers, open source databases, and containers. Windows Server licensing is counted per core plus a CAL for each user or device, while Linux can use a distribution subscription or a community distribution. Many offices end up using both.

The Linux vs Windows Server question usually comes up when an office buys a new server, moves applications to a virtual server, or when an old server approaches the end of its support. The answer is rarely about which system is better. Four things decide it: the applications that must run, the licensing model, the support lifecycle, and who will maintain the server day to day. This article covers all four, without price figures, because license prices differ by purchasing channel and change over time.

Linux vs Windows Server: a quick comparison

AspectLinuxWindows Server
Suited toWeb servers, modern applications, open source databases, containersActive Directory, .NET Framework applications, vendor software that only supports Windows
Licensing modelDistribution subscription (e.g. RHEL, Ubuntu Pro) or community distribution (e.g. Debian)Per physical core, plus a CAL for every user or device that accesses it
Support lifecycleDepends on the distribution: Ubuntu LTS 5 years standard, up to 10 years with Ubuntu Pro; RHEL 10 yearsFixed lifecycle: mainstream support for at least 5 years, then extended support with security updates only
How it is managedCommand line over SSH, script automationGraphical interface and PowerShell
Skills neededLinux adminWindows and Active Directory admin
Illustration: server

Start from the applications you must run

Applications are the first deciding factor, because the server operating system is only where applications run. List everything that will be installed, then check each one’s requirements:

  • Active Directory Domain Services (AD DS). AD DS is the Windows Server directory service that stores user accounts, computers, and network resources, and governs sign-in and access rights with a single username and password. Offices that manage dozens of Windows computers through a domain usually need it. Samba on Linux can act as an Active Directory domain controller, but its documentation states that the fully supported functional level is only equivalent to Windows Server 2008 R2, and Group Policy has to be enabled manually.
  • .NET applications. Modern .NET (formerly .NET Core) runs on Windows, Linux, and macOS. By contrast, .NET Framework is a Windows component, and some of its technologies, such as ASP.NET Web Forms and Windows Workflow Foundation, are not available in modern .NET. Older applications built on .NET Framework practically stay on Windows Server.
  • Microsoft SQL Server. SQL Server has run on Linux since version 2017, using the same database engine as the Windows version. SQL Server 2025 is supported on Red Hat Enterprise Linux and Ubuntu. So SQL Server does not automatically force Windows, unless its companion application needs Windows.
  • Vendor software. For accounting, ERP, or specialised software, the vendor’s official requirements decide. An operating system not listed in those requirements risks not being supported when problems arise.

Licensing model: per core and CAL, or a distribution subscription

The Windows Server 2025 licensing model is core-based. For a physical server, all physical cores must be licensed, with a minimum of 8 core licenses per processor and 16 core licenses per server. In addition, every user or device that accesses the server needs a CAL (Client Access License): a User CAL for one user on any device, or a Device CAL for one device used by anyone. The two can be mixed.

The edition also determines the number of virtual machines:

Windows Server 2025 editionVirtualization rights (per physical core licensing)Notes
StandardTwo operating system environments (OSEs) or two Hyper-V containersAdditional VMs mean relicensing all cores for every two OSEs
DatacenterUnlimited OSEsFor servers running many VMs
EssentialsOne instanceOEM only, for small businesses with up to 25 users and 50 devices

Linux has two routes:

  1. Distribution subscription. Red Hat Enterprise Linux (RHEL) is used with a subscription that provides access to updates, security fixes, and technical support. Ubuntu can be installed without a subscription, while Ubuntu Pro extends security updates and covers packages in the Universe repository.
  2. Community distribution. Debian and similar distributions are maintained by the community. Security updates are available, but no party is obliged to help when the server has a problem. That support must come from an internal team or a service provider.

License cost is not the only cost. Admin time, training, and third-party support are often larger than the licensing difference, so compare the total cost over the server’s lifetime.

Support lifecycle: the dates to note

The support lifecycle determines how long the operating system receives security updates. A server past that date keeps running, but new security holes are no longer patched. Microsoft divides Windows Server support into mainstream support (security and non-security updates) and extended support (security updates only).

VersionMainstream / standard support endsExtended / Pro support ends
Windows Server 2016January 2022January 2027
Windows Server 2019January 2024January 2029
Windows Server 2022October 2026October 2031
Windows Server 2025November 2029November 2034
Ubuntu 22.04 LTSMay 2027May 2032 (Ubuntu Pro)
Ubuntu 24.04 LTSMay 2029May 2034 (Ubuntu Pro)
Ubuntu 26.04 LTSMay 2031May 2036 (Ubuntu Pro)
Debian 12June 2026 (enters LTS phase)June 2028 (LTS)
Debian 13August 2028 (estimated, enters LTS phase)June 2030 (LTS)

RHEL uses a ten-year lifecycle per major version, with add-ons for certain minor releases. Debian LTS is run by a group of volunteers and companies, not the Debian security team, with the goal of a lifetime of at least five years.

Note the first row of the table: offices still running Windows Server 2016 have until January 2027 before regular security updates stop. After that, security updates are only available through the Extended Security Update program if Microsoft offers it.

The admin skills available

The safest server is one that is maintained properly, and that depends on the people maintaining it. Before deciding, answer three questions:

  1. Who installs updates every month? Installing updates and checking the results must be routine, on Linux and Windows alike.
  2. Who can recover the server at midnight? A team used to PowerShell and the Windows graphical interface will be slow on a Linux server reachable only over SSH, and the other way around.
  3. Is the configuration documented? Documentation recording what is installed, where, and why keeps the server maintainable if the admin changes.

If the internal team only knows one system, the choice that matches that skill is often safer than the choice that is cheaper on paper.

Common combinations in mid-sized offices

Linux and Windows Server do not have to be an either-or choice. Examples of a split that often makes sense:

Server roleTypical operating systemReason
Domain controller and shared filesWindows ServerWindows accounts and computers are managed through Active Directory
Internal web applicationLinuxWeb servers and containers are commonly run on Linux
DatabaseFollows the applicationPostgreSQL and MySQL are common on Linux, SQL Server can run on both
Vendor applicationPer vendor requirementsSo the vendor still supports it when problems arise

This example is an illustration, not a design for a particular office. Where to place it, an office server or the cloud, is discussed in Office Server, Cloud, or Shared Hosting, while CPU, RAM, and storage sizing is covered in Sizing a Server for Internal Applications.

Checklist before deciding

  1. List all applications that will run, along with each vendor’s official operating system requirements.
  2. Decide whether the office needs Active Directory for accounts and computers.
  3. Count the physical cores and the number of users or devices if choosing Windows Server.
  4. Decide whether paid support from the distribution provider is needed if choosing Linux.
  5. Note the end-of-support date of the version to be installed, and choose a version whose support outlasts the planned server lifetime.
  6. Make sure someone knows the system, within the team or through a service provider.

How Legia does it

In the Server Installation & Management service, Legia handles physical servers in the office, virtual servers, and cloud, on both Linux and Windows Server. Work begins with an infrastructure audit of 3-7 working days, followed by operating system hardening and patching, a firewall, SSH keys and two-factor authentication for admin access, per-person access rights, and access logs. The configuration is documented so another team can continue. Under monthly management, the monthly report covers server availability, incidents, security updates installed, and resource usage. Paid software licenses are billed by their vendors, and server accounts are created in your company’s name. Other services in this pillar are on the IT Infrastructure & Cloud page.

Frequently asked questions

Is Linux always more economical than Windows Server?

Not always. Community distributions do not require a paid operating system license, but support subscriptions, admin time, and training still count. If the main application is only supported on Windows, forcing Linux actually adds cost.

Can a .NET application be moved to Linux?

Yes, if the application uses modern .NET. A .NET Framework application has to be migrated to modern .NET first, and parts that use Windows-only technologies, such as ASP.NET Web Forms, have to be rewritten.

Does a Linux server need a subscription?

It is not required, but consider one if the server runs important systems and the internal team does not yet know Linux. An RHEL or Ubuntu Pro subscription gives longer security updates, and RHEL also provides technical support from Red Hat.

We still use Windows Server 2016. What is the first step?

Inventory the applications on that server and check whether all of them are supported on Windows Server 2025 or on Linux. Plan the migration before January 2027, when extended support for Windows Server 2016 ends.

Sources

Category IT Infrastructure & Cloud

Keep reading

Related articles

All Articles